The performance audit and sunset review of the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) found numerous flaws within the department statutorily responsible for regulating the insurance industry and financial institutions in Arizona, such as banks and credit unions as well as financial service professionals and/or business entities. The department also administers programs to deter automobile theft in the state.
State insurance departments play a critical role in protecting consumers access to affordable healthcare.
According to last month’s report, DIFI took steps to meet some statutory responsibilities but did not consistently determine if licensee violations were corrected and lacked documented explanations for some enforcement actions, increasing risk of future violations and public harm. From the report,
Department did not consistently consider licensee history or follow up to ensure violations were corrected, and lacked documentation explaining how it determined some enforcement actions, increasing risk of public harm and unequal treatment of licensees.
Arizona law also requires public employees and officers to avoid conflicts of interest that could influence their official actions. To determine if a conflict exists, they must assess whether they or a relative have a substantial interest in:
- Any contract, sale, purchase, or service involving the public agency.
- Any decision made by the public agency.
The regulatory department’s independent review organization (IRO) and its individual reviewers are contracted to review healthcare appeals and are prohibited from having substantial interests in certain entities related to cases under review or any other conflict of interest that would preclude the reviewer from making a fair and impartial decision.
The sunset audit also found DIFI did not comply with some state conflict-of-interest requirements and its conflict-of-interest process was not fully aligned with recommended practices.
Department’s noncompliance with some state conflict-of-interest requirements increased risk that employees and board/committee members did not disclose substantial interests that might influence or affect their official conduct
Auditor Findings:
- The department used a disclosure form for employees and board/committee members that did not address all statutorily required disclosures.
- Board members did not fully disclose substantial interests in department’s official public records.
- DIFI’s special disclosure file did not contain all disclosures of a substantial interest as required by statute.
- The department didn’t ensure its contracted IRO complied with statutory conflict-of-interest requirement for one healthcare appeals case auditor’s reviewed.
Auditors also found that although DIFI had aligned its conflict-of-interest process with some recommended practices, it did not always follow its process.
The Arizona Auditor General also showcased several deficiencies in the DIFI’s processes including significant delays in its average review time for long-term care insurance rate filings.
And the lack of oversight of recipients’ use of ATA Fund monies including $4.5 million appropriated to the Arizona Vehicle Theft Task Force in fiscal year 2023. The report detailed the department’s deficiencies:
- Did not ensure monies appropriated to the Task Force were spent on authorized uses.
- Did not ensure vertical prosecution grant monies for an awarded grant we reviewed were used for intended purposes related to reducing automobile theft.
Key Recommendations from the Report
The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions Should:
- Develop and implement policies and procedures consistent with recommended practices for all license types, including requirements to consider licensee history, follow up to ensure violations are corrected, and document how it determined enforcement actions.
- Revise and implement its conflict-of-interest policies and procedures to align with all State requirements and recommended practices.
- Ensure ATA Fund monies are used for authorized purposes.
The department agreed with all but two of the Arizona Auditor Generals’ findings and plans to implement or implement in a different manner all but one of the report’s recommendations.
Department Director Barbara Richardson,
The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) worked closely with the Arizona Auditor General’s team over the last year and appreciates the perspective the audit team provided throughout the process and in the final report. DIFI’s written response to the Auditor General’s report demonstrates the Department’s commitment to implementing the recommendations and continuously improving DIFI’s operations.
In September, the same month the Arizona Auditor General published its report, DIFI sent its FY 2026 budget request to Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs.
In the summer of 2020, DIFI was created when lawmakers consolidated the Arizona Department of Financial Institutions and the ATA as divisions within the Arizona Department of Insurance and renamed the combined agency the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions.
According to the report, the department’s fiscal year (FY) 2024 expenditures were estimated at about $24.4 million. Most of the department’s expenditures were for payroll and related benefits, transfers to the Arizona Department of Public Safety primarily for the Arizona Vehicle Theft Task Force, professional and outside services, and other operating costs.
In total, DIFI’s revenues are estimated at $868.7 million; most of the department’s revenues must be remitted to the State General Fund, the Firefighters’ Relief and Pension Fund, and the Public Safety Personnel Retirement System.



Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.