• Home
  • About
    • What We Do
    • THR In the News
    • Our Founder & Publisher
    • Our History
    • Founding Sponsors
    • Community Partners
    • Advisors
  • Top of Day
  • News
    • Arizona News
    • National News
  • Member Resources
    • Comings & Goings
    • 2022 State of the State Post-Conference Resources
    • Industry Links
    • White Papers, E books, Reports and more
    • Toolbox
  • Professional Directory
    • THR Business Directory
    • Member Directory
    • Founding Sponsors
    • Community Partners
    • Advisors
    • Corporate Profile Intake Form
    • Corporate Profile Change Request
  • Newsletter/Data
    • The Hertel Report February 2026 Newsletter
    • Data Resources
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Events/Products
  • Register
  • Log in
The Hertel Report
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • Become a Member
  • My Membership
  • My Profile
The Hertel Report
  • Home
  • About
    • What We Do
    • THR In the News
    • Our Founder & Publisher
    • Our History
    • Founding Sponsors
    • Community Partners
    • Advisors
  • Top of Day
  • News
    • Arizona News
    • National News
  • Member Resources
    • Comings & Goings
    • 2022 State of the State Post-Conference Resources
    • Industry Links
    • White Papers, E books, Reports and more
    • Toolbox
  • Professional Directory
    • THR Business Directory
    • Member Directory
    • Founding Sponsors
    • Community Partners
    • Advisors
    • Corporate Profile Intake Form
    • Corporate Profile Change Request
  • Newsletter/Data
    • The Hertel Report February 2026 Newsletter
    • Data Resources
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Events/Products
Home
Resources

Study Suggests Virus Symptom Screening in SNFs Won’t Help Curb the Spread – Arizona Facilities Fighting the Virus

April 29th, 2020 Veronica Graff Arizona News, Arizona News, Arizona Resources, CMS Rules, National News, News, Resources, Top of The Day

The spread of coronavirus in nursing homes has yielded disturbing death tolls among residents and a new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine confirms people infected with the virus are contributing to the spread without displaying any symptoms.

The study concludes that “rapid and widespread” transmission of the virus was demonstrated in the surveyed facility, of which more than half the residents who tested positive were asymptomatic at the time of testing, despite contributing to the spread.

Infection-control strategies relying on symptoms were deemed insufficient in curbing the spread of the virus within the facility. In Arizona, nursing home cases are only becoming more saturated with 22 residents testing positive at a Chandler long-term care facility across the street from an assisted living home that recorded 13 deaths due to virus complications.

The results echo early findings of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that concluded symptom-based screening of residents fail to identify all infections and asymptomatic residents may be contributing to the transmission of the virus.

Researchers found 10 of the 13 residents testing positive without symptoms began to show signs of the virus within seven days of the test. In Tucson, one nursing home has reported over 80 residents and staff who have tested positive for the virus. Maricopa County alone is reporting more than 400 cases among residents. Over half the total virus death toll in Pima County has been attributed to long-term care residents.

And a recent Good Samaritan executive order from Gov. Doug Ducey may make it more difficult for families to sue facilities for coronavirus-related care. The order sets the bar higher for civil suits citing negligence in facilities by specifying “gross negligence or reckless or willful misconduct.”

In order to file suit, families would have to prove administrators or employees knowingly and voluntarily disregarded reasonable care standards, according to experts. The order makes it harder for families to receive settlements from damages caused by the virus.

Goldberg & Osborne Attorney John Osborne told The Arizona Republic, “It’s a horrible shame that in the name of protecting healthcare workers the rights of the rest of the citizens of the state should be attacked in this cold and callous manner.”

He adds,

This isn’t going to help anybody except the profits of the nursing home.

For the full study, visit the New England Journal of Medicine’s site.

Find the CDC study here.

Also, view The Arizona Republic’s piece for more on Ducey’s executive order.

Check out Skilled Nursing News’ article and take a look at The Arizona Daily Star for more.

Plus, 12 News and ABC 15 providing some insight on the Arizona nursing facility story.

  • Tags
  • asymptomatic
  • coronavirus pandemic
  • Gov. Doug Ducey
  • long-term care facilities
  • nursing homes
  • Skilled Nursing Facilities
  • virus spread
Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest
Next article Arizona Moves to Protect SNFs from Treatment Liabilities Amid Global Pandemic
Previous article Supreme Court Rules HHS Must Pay Insurer Risk-Corridor Payments Under ACA

Veronica Graff

Business journalist and recent graduate from the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication with minors in business and philosophy. Emphasis in financial, economic and market reporting. Regular contributor to The Hertel Report.

Related Posts

National News

Elevance Health Medicare Advantage Enrollment Suspended

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a notice to Elevance Health that it will no...
Arizona News

Arizona Officials Respond to Prison Healthcare Receivership Order

Late last month, U.S. District Judge Rosalyn Silver ordered Arizona's prison healthcare system into...
National News

CMS Extends Hospital at Home Waiver

Early last month, President Donald Trump signed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2026, which included a...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Home
  • About
  • Top of Day
  • News
  • Member Resources
  • Professional Directory
  • Newsletter/Data
  • Events/Products
  • Back to top
© The Hertel Report 2017. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy